Best Sandwich Maker

In a Hurry? Editors choice:
Hamilton
Test Winner: Hamilton
Amazon Link
You know what? Somedays a plain old sandwich with soft bread and cold cheese just won't cut it. A sandwich only gets better once it is pressed or lightly grilled. This may seem like a daunting task early in the morning, or even on a lazy afternoon. But now, thanks to the design of a sandwich maker, we are now able to prepare our favorite combinations in an instant, and without a pile of dirty pans. Most styles of sandwich makers can also be used to create other delicious delicacies, such as pastries, grilled cheese, and miniature omelets. With their rising popularity and ease of use, the market has been flooded with options. Check out the current best of the best below.

Standout Picks

Hamilton
This brand believes in customer satisfaction. Hence, it offers the best products. This item happens to be one of them. It can be used by professionals in cafes and also indoors by individuals for their families. It works amazingly in both ways. You can also make pizzas and melt cheese in it along with open face sandwiches. This brilliant product helps you to make any recipe within 10 minutes. It makes healthier sandwiches as it helps in low-fat cooking. It comes with an extra dripping tray that collects the extra oil. Hence, it attracts more people because of its health-conscious features.
Amazon Link
$44.99
Cuisinart
This is a well-made, affordable option, and it has two color variants which are black and grey. It has a classy look and is designed to complement all the other appliances in your beautiful kitchen.
Amazon Link
$28.73
T-Fal EZ Clean
The name says it all, EZ Clean. This sandwich maker/waffle maker has interchangeable and dishwasher safe nonstick plates. This is a great lightweight option from a trusted brand.
Amazon Link
Oster XL Titanium
This next product is a 2 in 1 countertop grill and sandwich maker. It is larger than most of the other options on our list, allowing it to accommodate more sandwiches.
Amazon Link
$49.95
Philips
Philips is one of the most famous and respectable brands. The product is designed for nuclear families and couples. If you are too lazy to wake up early to make breakfast, then this is the best device for you to have your breakfast in bed with your partner. This sandwich maker has a perfect space for two sandwiches. It has a non-stick coating, quite strong build and the durability is amazing. The black body gives it a great look. The surface is non-sticky due to its coating which eventually makes it easier to clean. It has space for two slices only and it's ready to cook sandwich maker.
Amazon Link
Oster
It is an intelligent and amazing product and from Oster. You can create great masterpieces of grilled sandwiches anywhere anytime using this device. The experience of making a sandwich using this product is absolutely different.
Amazon Link
George Foreman
This list wouldn't be complete without an entry from George Foreman. It seems as though they have dropped their slogan and the sandwich maker/grill hybrids are selling themselves now. This particular model features a cooking surface of 66 square inches.
Amazon Link
Prestige
This is the perfect choice if you are looking for a reliable brand of household appliances in the market for household products.
Amazon Link
Isiler
The multifunction of this product makes it unique from all other products. Its opening is up to 180 degree which is great for grilling or making paninis. There are two traps on the sie of the plates to catch any grease before it hits the counter, making clean up a breeze.
Amazon Link
$49.95
Morphy Richards
This company has launched yet another masterpiece, with this sandwich maker. The two-slice item comes with all the features you are looking for.
Amazon Link

Criteria Used for Evaluation

Value

Buying a sandwich maker is not an expense but an investment. Why is that so? Just imagine the amount of money you spend on ordering a sandwich from a local shop. Even if you order once a week, you still end up spending more than making your own toast using this gadget. However, it is imperative that you are aware of what you need to look for in a good sandwich maker prior to making a purchase. Even an expensive sandwich maker might turn into a huge disappointment if you do not pick it carefully per your requirements. If you choose with the right knowledge and you keep your standards in mind while buying, then even an inexpensive one might turn out to be the best sandwich maker for you. That’s why it’s recommended to set a budget before buying and then choose amongst the shortlisted sandwich maker.

Brand

Sandwich makers are available in different sizes and shapes. These nifty kitchen tools are compact and ideal for anyone craving to have a quick snack. This tool can make simple sandwiches to more complex snacks like paninis. However, because we all want to get the most out of our money, we want to have something that will serve its purpose for a long time. That's where the brand comes in. We often times find ourselves buying name-brand items because we know that we can count on them being durability and accompanied by a decent warranty. Now, we aren't saying that the lesser-known brands don't create great products as well, but it's a known fact that Cuisinart, Oster, and Hamilton dominate the kitchen.

Size

The size or dimension is one of the most important things you should consider before buying any kitchen appliances. Sandwich maker comes in various sizes. You have to be mindful about this especially when you are buying one online. Always check the product’s dimension prior to making a purchase. A sandwich maker is an important appliance in the kitchen but you don’t want it to be so huge, that it takes too much space in your kitchen. What dimension you require also depends on the number of sandwiches you want to make in one go or you can count as per the number of people who are going to consume it at the same time.

Usually, you can make two sandwiches at a time but you can also buy four sandwich slice maker as per your requirements. The bigger one is preferred by most of the users as it provides a larger surface to place more sandwiches at one go. Also, bigger sandwich makers are less time consuming and if you are concerned about electricity then it saves a lot too. People, who live all by themselves, prefer smaller sandwich maker. Mostly, for bachelors, smaller sizes turn out to be the best sandwich maker. Small in size can fit anywhere in the house, especially if you keep moving from one house to another or if your kitchen is small. It is way more affordable than the bigger one. Some people who prefer to travel may also opt for a smaller and more compact type of this item. With this, they can easily pack it into their bags without any hassle.

Features

A good sandwich maker will have many advanced features. It will allow the user to prepare meals and snacks in different modes using this kitchen tool. Apparently, they are more expensive than the old-fashioned ones.

Handle Material
Since a sandwich maker is an electronic device that is used daily, you need to make sure that its handle is of high quality. The handle is an important feature because if it breaks, using the device will become a hectic task. You will come across different materials that are used for the handles. It could be made of plastic, metal and many more. Depending on the material, the handles have their own share of advantages and disadvantages. Usually, the ones that come with a plastic handle, are most likely to get damaged after a point of time especially if you use the sandwich maker on a daily basis. On the other hand, steel or metal handles are stronger and tend to last longer since it adds more strength to the product. The type of handle completely depends on the requirements and the usage of the user. Hence, choose the handle material wisely and carefully.

Surface Type
The major thing you should look for after dimension is Surface Type. The material of the surface is very important as it determines the efficiency and the quality the sandwich maker provides. Teflon is the coating that tends to last longer and it is a better choice for most people since it is easy to clean.

Non-stick Coating
Make sure that you look for the non-stick coating. The non-stick coating makes it easier for you to clean your appliance after using it. It also enables you to remove the sandwiches out easily without any cracks and without the trouble of removing sticking sandwiches on the surface.

Removable Plates
This is a hygiene oriented feature which you should look for since it helps you to clean it with ease after every use. Usually, all types of sandwich makers have removable plates so that you can wash them easily. Since it’s an electronic device, you cannot rinse the entire body otherwise it will damage the inbuilt machinery of the sandwich marker.

Adjustable Heat Settings
There are sandwich makers that feature heat settings. Not many of them have this feature but if you come across one, don’t forget all the customizable features it will provide you. If it falls within your budget, don’t think twice. With these heat settings, you can easily make a sandwich depending on your preference. Mostly, sandwich makers have only two light indicators- red and green. The green light indicates that your sandwich is done and is ready to serve.

Top 10 Picks

1. Hamilton

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$44.99
Hamilton
Amazon Link

This brand believes in customer satisfaction. Hence, it offers the best products. This item happens to be one of them. It can be used by professionals in cafes and also indoors by individuals for their families. It works amazingly in both ways. You can also make pizzas and melt cheese in it along with open face sandwiches.

This brilliant product helps you to make any recipe within 10 minutes. It makes healthier sandwiches as it helps in low-fat cooking. It comes with an extra dripping tray that collects the extra oil. Hence, it attracts more people because of its health-conscious features.

Read more

Value
This beauty is expensive but also useful for professionals or for someone who would like to have a cafe-like sandwich at home.

Brand Recognition
This is one of the leading houseware, cookware & kitchenware manufacturers around the globe.

Size
The dimension of the product is 11.4 x 31.2 x 32 cm. It provides great tasting Panini at home. You can stuff as much as you want since it is a grill for sandwiches of any type of thickness.

Features
It has a floating lid that presses down evenly which makes the sandwich look even better. It has power & preheats lights. It also allows upright storage with 10" x 8" nonstick grids.

Amazon Link
$44.99

2. Cuisinart

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$28.73
Cuisinart
Amazon Link

This is a well-made, affordable option, and it has two color variants which are black and grey. It has a classy look and is designed to complement all the other appliances in your beautiful kitchen.

Read more

Value
Every great product comes at a great price. This is a bit costly than other brands. However, it is affordable for your day to day modern life. There are usually various offers running online to get this beautiful device.

Brand Recognition
Cuisinart happens to be a popular brand amongst all the branded home appliances.

Size
The space-saving kitchen tool can be stored vertically, allowing you to have more space in your kitchen. The dimensions of this product are 10.1" x 9.7" x 5.3".

Features
This is one of the best sandwich makers as it has all the useful features you need. It is simple and easy to use. It grills sandwiches easily through its fixed grill plates while its hinged lock provides convenient sealing. It is very fast in grilling while minimizing cost.

Amazon Link
$28.73

3. T-Fal EZ Clean

Where to buy
Amazon Link
T-Fal EZ Clean
Amazon Link

The name says it all, EZ Clean. This sandwich maker/waffle maker has interchangeable and dishwasher safe nonstick plates. This is a great lightweight option from a trusted brand.

Read more

Value
The price of this sandwich maker is about average. It comes with a one-year limited warranty.

Brand Recognition
T-fal started making appliances back in 1956. Their strong and reliable products have gained popularity in over 120 countries. They are most well-known for their first product, the nonstick pan, but have branched out to many other appliances as well.

Size
This product weighs 4.5-pounds and the dimensions are 12.7” x 11.9” x 6.8”. It can fit two sandwiches or two waffles. This product can also be stored vertically to save room.

Features
This sandwich maker doubles as a waffle maker. The nonstick plates are removable and can be placed in the dishwasher. There are two lights on the outside, red and green, that indicate when the device is on and when it is ready.

Amazon Link

4. Oster XL Titanium

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$49.95
Oster XL Titanium
Amazon Link

This next product is a 2 in 1 countertop grill and sandwich maker. It is larger than most of the other options on our list, allowing it to accommodate more sandwiches.

Read more

Value
Considering the size and power of this machine, it is well worth the price. This sandwich maker can fit up to three sandwiches at one time and cooks 30% faster, saving you money on electricity.

Brand Recognition
In just about any kitchen you will be able to find at least one Oster brand appliance. Sunbeam-Oster has been putting out quality products since 1989 and shows no signs of slowing down.

Size
As mentioned, this device can cook up to three sandwiches at a time. It weighs 8.2-pounds. The dimensions are 6.8” x 15” x 13.6”.

Features
The features are really where this product shines. This sandwich maker can be opened up fully and laid flat to be used as a countertop grill. It can be heated up to 110 degrees and has a DuraCeramic nonstick coating. The device also features a “floating hinge” system that accommodates sandwiches of all thickness.

Amazon Link
$49.95

5. Philips

Where to buy
Amazon Link
Philips
Amazon Link

Philips is one of the most famous and respectable brands. The product is designed for nuclear families and couples. If you are too lazy to wake up early to make breakfast, then this is the best device for you to have your breakfast in bed with your partner. This sandwich maker has a perfect space for two sandwiches.

It has a non-stick coating, quite strong build and the durability is amazing. The black body gives it a great look. The surface is non-sticky due to its coating which eventually makes it easier to clean. It has space for two slices only and it's ready to cook sandwich maker.

Read more

Value
In terms of prices, this one comes with the best price and it’s quite affordable for working couples, who don’t invest much time in cooking because of their lifestyle.

Brand Recognition
It is a well-known brand across the globe. It is known for its affordable and good quality appliances.

Size
The dimension of the product is 30.5 x 30.5 x 15.2 cm and it weighs 1.74kgs. The cord winding facility makes the product more prudential.

Features
The rubber feet ensure that the sandwich maker doesn't move and will stay in its place. Its cool handle gives a good grip to the person holding it. It has an easy push-down lock system while its especially non-stick coating makes the cleaning easier.

The device is vertical with a compact storage. It provides high power for fast heating up with a ready to cook light indicator. The device has a good power of 820 watts.

Amazon Link

6. Oster

Where to buy
Amazon Link
Oster
Amazon Link

It is an intelligent and amazing product and from Oster. You can create great masterpieces of grilled sandwiches anywhere anytime using this device. The experience of making a sandwich using this product is absolutely different.

Read more

Value
The quality is great but the price is extremely affordable.

Brand Recognition
It has great brand recognition for international brands.

Size
The product weighs 1.43 kg. Its dimensions are 9" x 9" x 2".

Features
The non-stick grill plate for easy clean-up is great. It comes with vertical storage and automatic thermostat control. Its power-on and ready indicator lights are helpful to know when your sandwich is ready. It has a voltage of 220 and a power of 700 watts.

Amazon Link

7. George Foreman

Where to buy
Amazon Link
George Foreman
Amazon Link

This list wouldn't be complete without an entry from George Foreman. It seems as though they have dropped their slogan and the sandwich maker/grill hybrids are selling themselves now. This particular model features a cooking surface of 66 square inches.

Read more

Value
This is one of the cheapest products on our list (if you choose the black color). If you decide on the platinum color, the price goes up quite a bit and puts it on par with most of our other additions. The great price does not affect the capabilities of this grill/sandwich maker.

Brand Recognition
Who hasn’t heard of the George Foreman Lean Mean Fat-Reducing Grilling Machine? If you were around in the 90s or the early 00s, you know what I’m talking about. These grills are well-known for their ease of use and the plethora of recipes that have been created specifically for George Foremans.

Size
This is a strong and compact machine. Its dimensions are 12.28” x 6.5” x 13.27” and it weighs 9.9-ounces. The grill itself if 60 square inches. This is ideal for anyone who is living in an apartment or has a small kitchen.

Features
With the nonstick plates of this product, you do not need to use any butter or oil when you cook your food. If you do happen to throw something juicy on the grill, the grill itself is angled and has a plate to catch the fat. It is claimed that this surface reduces the fat in your food by 42%. The plates are removable and can be put in the dishwasher.

Amazon Link

8. Prestige

Where to buy
Amazon Link
Prestige
Amazon Link

This is the perfect choice if you are looking for a reliable brand of household appliances in the market for household products.

Read more

Value
It is light on your pocket and gives a luxurious feel to your kitchen.

Brand Recognition
Its brand is one of the most popular amongst all the branded home appliances. It is the leading name in making home appliances.

Size
Before buying any product, most of us check the size of the product to make sure that it will function rightly on the place it is going to occupy in our kitchen. The product dimension is 25.7 x 23.8 x 11.1 cm, which is easy to place in your kitchen and weighs 1.2kg.

Features
Also, it is coated with non-stick plates which need less oil which helps to make the sandwiches healthier and cleaning becomes easy and less messy.

Amazon Link

9. Isiler

Where to buy
Amazon Link
$49.95
Isiler
Amazon Link

The multifunction of this product makes it unique from all other products. Its opening is up to 180 degree which is great for grilling or making paninis. There are two traps on the sie of the plates to catch any grease before it hits the counter, making clean up a breeze.

Read more

Value
This product is a steal! Considering all of the extra features that are included and the great warranty there is no reason not to give this one a try. It is easy to use, easy to clean, and easy to store.

Brand Recognition
Isiler is a less well-known company. They specialize in small appliances. The brand offers a 3-month money back guarantee and a 12-month replacement warranty.

Size
This sandwich maker is 12.5” x 4.8” x 10.3”. It is small and lightweight at only 4.95-pounds. It can fit two sandwiches at a time.

Features
This sandwich maker can be opened up to 90 degrees, like a traditional panini press or it can be opened to lay flat and used as a grill. It has an adjustable heat knob and nonstick plates. You can use this device to make vegetables, sandwiches, steaks, omelets, pizza, and many other meals.

Amazon Link
$49.95

10. Morphy Richards

Where to buy
Amazon Link
Morphy Richards
Amazon Link

This company has launched yet another masterpiece, with this sandwich maker. The two-slice item comes with all the features you are looking for.

Read more

Value
The product is worth your money. It comes with two years of warranty. You can get great deals and amazing discounts online.

Brand Recognition
In the world of electrical appliances, this is one of the biggest brands. Users value and respect this brand.

Size
The dimension of the product is 26.9 x 28.8 x 12.3 cm and it weighs 1.92 kg. This is a portable product. It saves your time in long cleaning hours as it is easy to clean.

Features
It also comes with a comfortable front handle which makes it easy to carry around. Its power is at 750 watts while its operating voltage is at 230 volts.

You can easily prepare an evenly grilled sandwich, which not only looks good but also tastes good. The indicator (neon colored lights) helps you to know when your sandwich is ready to eat.

Amazon Link

Sources

  1. Sarah Sikandhar, 10 best sandwich makers, Buying Guide
  2. Lydia Anderson, The best toastie makers for perfect cheese toasties, Good House Keeping